by
kendrive
@ 2007-02-24 - 12:58:17

Parents have called for the return of the cane to restore order in the classroom.
Families told a Government-backed study that discipline had deteriorated since corporal punishment was abolished more than 20 years ago. Many parents also said that teachers had less power to enforce good behaviour and backed the idea of a "boot camp" for disruptive pupils.
However, most people advocated a return to more traditional schooling methods. According to the report published yesterday, the key issue for the majority of parents was discipline.
The following article is by Andrew Gimson, the parliamentary sketch writer for The Daily Telegraph:
IS IT A SHAME WE LOST THE CANE?
"Bring back the cane." So said parents when Mori conducted some research for the Department of Education into its school reforms.
This was not the response the Government was looking for. It appears to have hoped that it would instead receive parents’ backing for trust schools.
But parents have better things to do than follow every twist and turn of the Government’s finicky and half-baked educational reforms.
As a traditionalist, one cannot help being heartened by the refusal of the British public to adopt the pallid liberal agenda of the dreaded educational establishment.
Caning has been out of the news for years. Any Tory who had the temerity to call for its return at the party conference would inflict a nervous breakdown on the present leadership. Like old ladies in hats, the hangers and floggers have vanished from the political stage.
And yet it is quite odd that we have decided we can do without such a long-established form of punishment.
The cane has great advantages as a way of dealing with unruly children. It is quick and cheap, and many a child, offered a choice between being beaten and some longer and more tedious punishment, has opted for six of the best.
I was beaten at school. I won’t say it did me no harm, for it seems to me that men who say that often look a bit damaged. But I do remember that while it was astonishingly painful, it was over very quickly and one could try to adopt a semi-heroic pose afterwards.
To my astonishment, when I asked my 11-year-old daughter Eliza whether she was in favour of the cane, she said that she was. For according to her, “Kids aren’t really going to care if the teacher just says something. But they’re going to care if they get hurt.”
But when I put the same question to my son Clive, who is seven, he said: “No, because it’s cruel.” Katy, who is five, is also against the cane, because she doesn’t want children to get hurt.
My wife says to bring back the cane would be outrageous and even to think of doing so is a reflection of British society’s brutal attitude to children.
My own feeling is that we shall only reap the full benefits of the cane if it is combined with a regime of cold baths.